The Editing Process Demystified: What Every Author Needs to Know Before Publishing
/
You’ve finished your manuscript—congratulations! That’s a major milestone. But before you rush to hit "publish," there's a critical step that separates professional books from amateur efforts: editing.
Many first-time authors underestimate how many layers go into high-quality book editing. And skipping (or skimping on) this process can lead to poor reviews, lost credibility, and missed opportunities to make the impact your book was designed to have.
At Bestsellers with Brooke-Sidney™, we guide authors through the entire editorial journey to ensure their message is clear, powerful, and ready for readers. If you're unsure what kind of editing your book needs—or when to do what—this post will break it all down.
Why Editing Is Not Optional
Even the most talented writers don’t publish without editing. Why? Because writing is a creative process—and editing is a critical, strategic one. While your first draft captures the heart of your message, editing turns that raw potential into a polished, professional product.
Editing isn’t just about fixing typos. It’s about structure, tone, pacing, clarity, and delivering a high-quality reader experience. In fact, there are multiple types of editing, and each one serves a distinct purpose.
Let’s break them down.
1. Developmental Editing (Also Called Substantive Editing)
This is the big picture stage.
A developmental editor looks at the overall structure, flow, and logic of your manuscript. Are your ideas organized in a way that makes sense? Are you missing any chapters or repeating yourself? Is your message clear—and does each section support it?
Developmental editing often involves:
Chapter restructuring
Clarifying your core message
Strengthening story arcs or frameworks
Adding or removing content
At Bestsellers with Brooke-Sidney™, this stage is where many first-time authors receive the most support. We make sure your book is aligned with your voice, your audience, and your goals.
2. Line Editing
Once your structure is solid, it’s time to refine the language.
Line editing focuses on the style and flow of your sentences. It’s about making sure your writing is clear, engaging, and consistent. A good line edit polishes your prose while preserving your unique voice.
It covers:
Word choice
Sentence clarity
Pacing and tone
Eliminating redundancies
This is where your book starts to sound like the best version of you. Your voice becomes sharper, and your message more impactful.
3. Copyediting
This is the detail-oriented stage.
Copyediting ensures that your manuscript follows grammar, punctuation, and spelling conventions. It also addresses formatting consistency, verb tense, word usage, and basic fact-checking.
At this stage, a copyeditor:
Fixes grammar and punctuation
Ensures style guide consistency (APA, Chicago Manual, etc.)
Checks for clarity and correctness
Identifies factual inconsistencies
Copyediting is often confused with proofreading—but it’s more in-depth and essential before final formatting.
4. Proofreading
The final polish.
Proofreading happens after your manuscript has been formatted for print or digital publishing. It’s your last chance to catch surface-level errors before the book goes to press or live online.
A proofreader checks for:
Typos
Formatting issues
Spacing errors
Missed punctuation
While this may seem small, it makes a huge difference in how professional your book appears. You never want to hear, “It was good, but full of errors.”
What Editing Path Is Right for You?
Here’s a simplified editing path we recommend for most nonfiction authors:
Developmental Edit (if you need structural help or haven’t worked with a coach)
Line Edit
Copyedit
Proofread
Not sure where you fall? At Bestsellers with Brooke-Sidney™, we do a full manuscript review to determine what stage your book is in and create a custom editing plan that fits your needs and publishing goals.
Why Invest in Professional Editing?
You might be tempted to rely on Grammarly or let a friend “look it over,” but editing a book is a specialized skill. A professional editor brings a trained eye, industry experience, and a reader’s perspective.
When you invest in professional editing, you’re investing in:
Your credibility as an author or expert
Your reader’s experience
Your book’s marketability and success
Remember: Readers may forgive an imperfect plot—but they rarely forgive bad writing.
Final Thoughts: A Beautiful Book Deserves a Beautiful Edit
Editing isn’t just the final step—it’s the transformational step that elevates your manuscript from good to unforgettable.
At Bestsellers with Brooke-Sidney™, we offer expert editing services for every stage of the publishing journey. Whether you're starting with a rough draft or nearly ready to launch, we'll help you refine your message and deliver a professional, polished book that makes you proud.
📅 Not sure what kind of editing you need?
Schedule a Book Chat and we’ll walk you through the next best step to get your book launch-ready.